Why Using Newer Si SJ MOSFETs May Not Be a Good Idea for High Frequency Switching
Key Takeaways:
· Output capacitance Coss-related loss is the major switching loss in resonant soft switching.
· New generations of silicon super-junction MOSFETs (SJ MOSFETs) dissipate more energy per switching cycle than legacy ones.
· Hysteresis of new generations of silicon super-junction is larger and increases with increasing dV/dt and peak Vds.
Resonant switching techniques are used to reduce the switching loss and increase the power density. Output capacitance (Coss) related loss is the major switching loss in resonant soft switching.
Two papers published in IEEE ISPSD (2018) and TPEL (2019) by G. Zulauf et al. (with Prof. Juan M. Rivas-Davila at Stanford University) showed that new generations of silicon super junction MOSFET are actually dissipating more energy (Ediss) than legacy ones with similar on-resistance. The data presented also show that the Ediss of silicon super junction MOSFET tends to increase with increasing frequency. That means a newer generation of silicon super junction MOSFET may be less suitable to be used in resonant topologies targeting high-frequency operations in spite of a lower stored output capacitance energy (Eoss) noted in the datasheet.
The Ediss is the energy dissipated during each cycle of charging and discharging of Coss. The newer generation of silicon super-junction MOSFET has a smaller pitch and higher doping concentration of n-type drift layer between p-type pillars in order to reduce die size and cost. There is another paper published in IEEE EDL (2019) by Z. Lin of Chongqing Univ. shows that these features may enhance non-linearity and hysteresis of the output charge (Qoss) versus the drain-source voltage Vds curves. The hysteresis area of Qoss-Vds curves also increases with increasing dV/dt in silicon super-junction MOSFETs. Since the hysteresis area is the energy lost during the charge/discharge cycle, this observation explains why Coss related switching loss would be higher for the newer generation of silicon super junction MOSFET, and also suggests that the effect of Ediss increasing with increased switching frequency (higher dV/dt) is going to be more significant for the newer generation of silicon super-junction MOSFETs.
- +1 Like
- Add to Favorites
Recommend
- C-V Curve Matters for Quiet Power Electronics
- ROHM’s New Class-Leading Low ON Resistance Nch MOSFETs: Delivering High Efficiency Operation in a Variety of Applications
- ROHM’s New N-channel MOSFETs Offer High Mounting Reliability in Automotive Applications
- SiC is quickly taking the market share originally occupied by Si IGBT in electric vehicles
- Vincotech‘s fastPACK 0 MOS and fastPACK 1 MOS Modules Featuring Cost-effective H-bridge Topology with MOSFETs
- The “Magic Bullet“ for High-Current Scenarios, the Advantages of WAYON TOLL MOSFETs Explained
- ILME SI 5 A Stamped Contacts: a Convenient Alternative
- Achieve Zero Switching Loss with SiC MOSFET
This document is provided by Sekorm Platform for VIP exclusive service. The copyright is owned by Sekorm. Without authorization, any medias, websites or individual are not allowed to reprint. When authorizing the reprint, the link of www.sekorm.com must be indicated.
Integrated Circuits
Discrete Components
Connectors & Structural Components
Assembly UnitModules & Accessories
Power Supplies & Power Modules
Electronic Materials
Instrumentation & Test Kit
Electrical Tools & Materials
Mechatronics
Processing & Customization
