Application Note
Railcar Couplings With
Wireless Network Technology
Anyone who frequently travels by rail will
know the situation: the train arrives on time,
but even before it reaches the platform the
station tannoy announces that the cars are
not in the order shown on the display board.
Sometimes there are even cars missing.
The result of this is that passengers on the
platform, and subsequently in the train, have
extreme difficulty locating their reserved
seats. When some of the expected cars are
not included, the corresponding reservations
will also be missing.
The reason for this confusion is that the
onboard technology lacks flexibility. Once a
train has been put together the car and seat
numbers are fixed and cannot be changed.
If shunting considerations cause the train to
leave the shed in the wrong direction, then
it will remain the wrong way around until it
reaches its destination. There is no way of
then renumbering the cars and seats. Customers
who are familiar with modern Ethernet
technology and flexible programming facilities
justifiably want to know why such straight-
forward adjustments are totally impossible
for modern high-speed trains.
If trains were equipped with broadband Ethernet
networking it would be possible to implement
this and numerous other applications that
airline passengers, for instance, have learned
to take for granted: onboard entertainment
offering a selection of films that can be
shown on request, e-mail access via an on-train
internet service, up-to-date information about
connections to other trains, delays, etc.
A broadband network would enable the onboard
staff to improve their proffered service by
providing a central overview of the occupancy
of individual cars. Video monitoring and fast-
response emergency services could also serve
to improve safety.
AN 101HE
Transportation
Hirschmann
Wireless LAN in trains
2
But even now, trains are equipped only with
cable-based networking. There are two reasons
for this – its robustness and its durability.
Broadband connections on board a train suffer
primarily from the fact that each of the
couplings between cars is a bottleneck that
impedes the flow of data. They are the most
heavily used connections and are subject to a
great deal of wear. Temperature fluctuations,
rain, snow and sleet, dirt and impacts from
loose chippings all demand extremely robust,
well-designed plugs and sockets for the cable
connections that have to pass through the
couplings. This is why trains still offer – at
best – digital bus technology or modulated
Ethernet via the UIC line. For many years,
Ethernet has been gradually ousting con-
ventional bus technology from the field of
industrial automation.
Bus technology is relatively simple and
extremely reliable, but it does not lend itself
to networking and many of the available forms
are mutually incompatible. Ethernet, on the
other hand, allows individual subscribers
to be networked and is a well standardized
technology (IEEE 802.3) that can therefore
be upgraded step by step at relatively low
cost anywhere in the world.
Ethernet networking not only permits high
data speeds, it also facilitates fast recognition
of the train configuration and is readily
extensible. To date, however, connections
through train couplings have – at best –
achieved rates of 10 Mbps. This is why a
wireless solution is so attractive.
Wireless LAN (WLAN), as described in the
IEEE802.11 standard, is a wireless Ethernet
network. To date the WLAN standard has
diversified into four variants, from the venerable
but still common IEEE802.11b standard, offer-
ing gross data rates of up to 11 Mbps, right
up to the brand new IEEE802.11n standard,
which currently offers up to 300 Mbps
and is scheduled to reach 450 Mbps in
a subsequent stage.
These rates are perfectly adequate for imple-
menting the desired facilities and services in
the train, and for future requirements such as
electronic rear-view mirrors or front cameras
to improve passenger comfort. A wireless net-
work can be installed in an existing network –
the existing cables and couplings do not need
to be modified.
Great Challenges Call
for Great Solutions
In practice there are a number of technical
problems that remain to be solved even with
a wireless LAN. Retrofitting WLAN access
points and (particularly) antennas in previously
delivered trains can be quite a challenge.
Every inch of space is already taken up.
Naturally, small easy-to-install units will
be advantageous here.
A further advantage can be achieved by
reducing the number of devices, e.g. by inte-
grating several WLAN interfaces into a single
access point. Naturally, the units also have to
meet all the standards required for equipment
that is installed in trains. These are stringent
requirements, and cannot be fulfilled by just
any device.
But the greatest challenge is due to the simple
fact that a wireless network has no external
boundary: electromagnetic waves do not
stop when they reach the side of the train.
A connection that is set up between two cars
or train sections needs to bridge only a very
short distance. It is particularly important
to prevent nearby trains from setting up
unwanted connections. And, naturally, there
have to be safeguards to prevent unauthorized
persons from gaining access to a train’s internal
network.
Modern WLAN equipment is perfectly able to
meet these requirements. Authentication and
encryption are mechanisms that are described
in the WLAN IEEE802.11i safety standard, which
is supported by almost all modern products.
Wireless Networking as the Basis for a Solution